Well, don't say I didn't warn you.
As I predicted in my last post (about four months ago), the one-two punch of grad school and wedding planning pretty much eradicated this blog from my priorities for a while. Now that my first semester is over, though, I'll be able to get caught up on all the awesome (and some not-so-awesome) music that's seen the light of day over the past year or so. And what better time of year to do so than as the year itself is coming to a close and everyone else with access to a keyboard is putting together their year-end recaps? You'll see plenty of list-making and recapping (is that a legitimate word?) here too.
But first, there are a few releases from the last couple months of 2010 that I never got around to mentioning, so I'll touch on those first:
- Definitely check out Joe Satriani's latest solo album, Black Swans And Wormhole Wizards: it's his most creative release in years, with plenty of Chickenfoot-inspired songwriting energy and a few off-the-wall touches (who would guess that T-Pain-esque autotune sounded so cool on a guitar?).
- The latest Alter Bridge release, AB III, is also pretty satisfying: Mark Tremonti and Myles Kennedy can churn out killer riffs like few other musicians I know of, and while sometimes the album starts to sound a little same-y, there's no denying just how good at their craft these guys are.
- Trapt also put out a new album last fall, No Apologies, and while it won't win any awards for virtuosity or innovation, it hits that high-school-metal guilty pleasure sweet spot; if that's your thing, give it a chance.
- Kings Of Leon released Come Around Sundown around the same time, an easy-going collection of radio-friendly Southern-tinged alt-rock tunes that's satisfying, if not life-changing.
- Underoath lost one of their two lead vocalists before recording and releasing 0 (Disambiguation), but the one remaining singer/screamer steps up to the plate admirably and fronts what might be the band's most crushing album yet; also, welcome touches of electronic atmosphere help diversify what could have been yet another monotonous metalcore album.
- Finally, My Chemical Romance released Danger Days: The True Lives Of The Fabulous Killjoys, and if you couldn't tell from the somewhat ridiculous title, it's a pretty pretentious affair; their songwriting has never been less memorable, and the whole album is weighed down by some half-baked concept about superheroes or something that the music itself really can't support. Avoid that one.
. . . There. Now that that's out of the way, we can move on to 2011. Everyone comfortable? Good, because this one's a doozy. I'll be breaking up my recap of the past year's music into three sections: the awesome stuff that you should definitely check out, the okay stuff that you might give a chance if you're so inclined, and the disappointing stuff that you should probably steer clear of. Here goes nothing . . .
The Awesome Stuff
- The Decemberists - The King Is Dead - Colin Meloy and bandmates ease up on their usual highbrow, conceptual approach to songwriting and decide to make a simple country-influenced folk-rock album, and the result is some of the group's best material. (An EP of leftovers, Long Live The King, was also released this year, and complements it nicely.)
- Scale The Summit - The Collective - Virtuosic instrumental prog-metal that, for all its technical skill, doesn't come across as blatantly shreddy most of the time. These guys have a great sense of melody, and although some ideas feel underdeveloped (some of the songs are surprisingly short), this is a blast to listen to without feeling exhausting.
- The Human Abstract - Digital Veil - One of THA's founding guitarists returned to the band after taking classical guitar training, and it shows in the band's new material. The songs here are meticulously crafted and extremely tightly played while still being downright brutal. The vocal performance on this one is also leaps and bounds better than their previous effort.
- Long Distance Calling - Long Distance Calling - Imagine some strange love-child conceived by Tool and Sigur Ros, and you'll have a vague idea of what LDC is all about - brooding, atmospheric instrumental post-metal that packs a punch. The self-titled album fine-tunes that formula perfectly, serving up chunky headbanging riffs and dreamy ambience in equal measure.
- Tesseract - One - Tesseract offers a decidedly more melodic, almost ethereal take on the heavily-syncopated and down-tuned style of the still-growing djent scene, and their debut album announces the band as a force to be reckoned with. Soaring melodies and extremely intricate, pummeling guitar and bass work have rarely sounded so good together.
- Radiohead - The King Of Limbs - The genre-defying icons' latest is one of their most low-key, introverted releases, so it takes a while to really show its true brilliance. Once the skittering programming and sinuous vocal work give up their secrets, though, it's a very satisfying listen.
- Between The Buried And Me - The Parallax: Hypersleep Dialogues - At only three songs and thirty minutes in length, BTBAM's latest EP almost feels skimpy enough not to count among this year's standout releases. However, there are enough crushingly epic moments here to make this one impossible to ignore.
- Foo Fighters - Wasting Light - Famously recorded in Dave Grohl's garage to analog tape, this is fittingly the Foos' most ass-kicking album since the Nineties, while still offering up hook after delicious hook. No frills, no pretension, just straight-up rock at its finest. The perfect album for cranking up in your car and singing along to (or air-drumming or -guitaring) at the top of your lungs.
- Thursday - No Devolucion - Thursday plays down their post-hardcore roots and cranks up the reverb-soaked atmosphere on this one, and it works to great effect. Definitely a mood album, and much different than their earlier work, but one of their best. Great for rainy days and being contemplative.
- Manchester Orchestra - Simple Math - These guys have a way of not really fitting into the molds of indie-rock, alternative rock, post-hardcore, or anything else. But they also have a way of making great music, and this album is no exception. Great lyrics and catchy melodies make this a blast to sing along to.
- Bon Iver - Bon Iver - Just about everyone else has been raving about this album lately, and I have to say, they're right - this is a beautiful work of minimalist indie-rock. Atmospheric playing and cryptic, yet somehow still emotionally resonant, lyrics make this album a joy to listen to.
- Symphony X - Iconoclast - If blistering, technical riffs, over-the-top shredding solos, epic orchestral/choral passages, and some of music's heavy-metal-est vocals this side of Ronnie James Dio are to your liking, look no further - Iconoclast has all of this in spades. In fact, one of the album's handicaps is that it can be too consistent in its constant bringing of the thunder.
- Incubus - If Not Now, When? - Incubus may have dialed way back on the overall level of energy and aggression with their latest, but their songwriting skills remain as finely-tuned as ever. This is quite a divisive album simply because it's such a radical change in style for the band, but they're still writing great songs and performing them with heart.
- Dream Theater - A Dramatic Turn Of Events - DT's first album without founding drummer Mike Portnoy, and their first with newcomer Mike Mangini, was always going to be a make-or-break moment for the band - and they nailed it. This is their most dynamic, well-balanced, and expertly-crafted album in years, and should signal the beginning of a thrilling new era for Dream Theater and its fans.
- Thrice - Major/Minor - For their previous album, Beggars, Thrice dialed back a bit on the heaviness present in their earlier work; much of that energy returns on this album, though, coupled with the band's continued maturation into masterful songwriters. Add this to Dustin Kensrue's fantastic lyrical work, and the result is a powerful, visceral, and moving album. Thrice's track record is already impeccable, but this is one of their best.
- Wilco - The Whole Love - The two sides of Wilco's music - experimental, willfully obtuse album rock and bright, jangly pop songs - tend to swing in and out of balance with each other over time, but they reached almost the perfect mixture with this release. It's an easily approachable, pleasant album, but one that reveals surprising depth if you give it a chance.
- Steven Wilson - Grace For Drowning - I'm still a huge fan of Wilson's first solo album, Insurgentes, and his new one expands on the already wide sonic palette present there. Avant-garde free jazz epics, choirs and orchestras, brooding ballads, and ominous electronic sound design come together to make this an adventurous and truly progressive listening experience.
- Animals As Leaders - Weightless - Similar to Scale The Summit's release this year, but a lot more over-the-top in terms of both heaviness and virtuosity, this is a tour-de-force of eight-string-guitar-led technical instrumental metal that still contains songs that will get stuck in your head. Mind-blowingly heavy at times, but still capable of beautiful moments, this one is an absolute blast.
- Chevelle - Hats Off To The Bull - Chevelle is nothing if not consistent, and this album continues their streak of accessible but satisfying alt-metal releases. Some of the band's best songwriting yet is on display here; also, in certain places, the vibe of their early-'00s breakthrough records shines through again, which is definitely welcome.
The Okay Stuff
For lovers of indie-rock and things generally on the lighter side: Iron And Wine released an album full of classic '70s- and '80s-inspired pop songs in Kiss Each Other Clean; Mogwai continued being probably the most sonically diverse post-rock band out there with Hardcore Will Never Die, But You Will; The Airborne Toxic Event released their second album, All At Once, full of solid (if just a little bland at times) songwriting and clever lyrics; Explosions In The Sky, unlike Mogwai, did little to expand their sound with Take Care, Take Care, Take Care, but still managed to create something epic and beautiful; Death Cab For Cutie put down their guitars for Codes And Keys and created their most keyboard-driven, pop-oriented album yet; Jack's Mannequin released People And Things, another album full of pleasant and well-written but by no means life-changing piano-pop songs; and Coldplay cranked up the shiny pop production values on Mylo Xyloto to compelling effect, while losing none of their inherent sing-along-ability.
Fans of '90s nostalgia had albums from Red Hot Chili Peppers and Jane's Addiction to look forward to this year, and both of them turned out pretty alright, if not fantastically. Both I'm With You and The Great Escape Artist are solid enough, but still have an air of older bands struggling for relevance and fresh-sounding material long after their heydays have passed.
For the metalheads: Red released Until We Have Faces and took strides to break their formula of orchestra-inflected alt-metal, which turned out quite well; Funeral For A Friend released their most energetic, spirited album in years with Welcome Home Armageddon; Protest The Hero put their impressive chops on display again with Scurrilous, delivering lots of shred but not quite as many memorable melodies; August Burns Red continued on their path of being a better-than-average and quite talented metalcore band with Leveler; Fair To Midland released Arrows & Anchors, a highly enjoyable and diverse album despite being just a bit overstuffed and filler-ridden; Trivium released the intentionally stripped-down In Waves, chock full of fun guitar riffs but lacking the amount of substance present in their previous effort; The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus released Am I The Enemy, a huge improvement over their dismal second album but still pretty run-of-the-mill emo-punk-metal; Staind returned to their heavy, angsty roots with their surprisingly enjoyable self-titled album; Opeth dropped all trace of death metal from their sound with Heritage, and crafted an admirably adventurous but at times frustratingly obtuse prog-rock album; Chickenfoot released Chickenfoot III (really only their second album), a collection of straight-ahead hard rock songs that can't quite escape the shadow of its predecessor; Machine Head released Unto The Locust, a satisfyingly heavy but somewhat abrasive album that didn't turn out quite as epic as it should have been; Mastodon crafted their first non-concept album, The Hunter, which is quite a fun listen, even though it lacks the ambition of their other work; Evanescence released their surprisingly tight and hook-filled self-titled album after half a decade of silence; Redemption returned with This Mortal Coil, a prog-metal epic with lots of impressive playing but a slight lack of dynamics and memorable songwriting; 3 released The Ghost You Gave To Me, continuing their trend of albums with plenty of great performances bogged down by just a few too many filler-ish tracks; Cynic released the EP Carbon-Based Anatomy, which turns firmly away from their earlier death-metal influences and in a more New-Age-y prog direction; and Korn showed an admirable willingness to experiment with dubstep on The Path To Totality, even though the results are spotty at best.
Oh yeah, and Umphrey's McGee released Death By Stereo, a diverse album jumping around from raucous jam-rock to trippy funk and everywhere in between which may disappoint those looking for another Mantis but delight listeners eager for something new. (They get their own paragraph because I couldn't figure out which of the ones above they fit in best. That alone should tell you something about this album.)
The Crappy Stuff
Yes, 2011 was a pretty great year, but it also saw its share of music that sucked. God knows there's plenty of terrible music out there, but there are only a few especially egregious offenders that I'll mention here - usually notable for being particularly disappointing releases from otherwise decent bands. Dredg is the first offender, deciding to ditch the prog-influenced alt-rock of their earlier work for blatantly processed, lazy pop on Chuckles And Mr. Squeezy. if the absurd title wasn't offensive enough, the lack of any obvious effort to write or perform decent songs makes this their worst album by far. Seether has released its share of mildly enjoyable radio metal, but Holding Onto Strings Better Left To Fray is a big miss. Almost every track feels like a tired rehash of a better song that they released two or three records ago, and lead singer Shaun Morgan has clearly run out of good lyrical ideas. Taking Back Sunday's self-titled album sounded great on paper, featuring the reunion of their original lineup from the early '00s, but the results are much less than the sum of their parts. It's a halfway-decent pop-punk album, but there's not much memorable going on, and it fails to stand up to its predecessors. And, predictably, Nickelback lands among the worst of the year with Here And Now. In the album's defense, it is an improvement over Dark Horse; most of the sappy Def Leppard-isms have been done away with, and there seems to be some more involved, intricate guitar playing happening on a few songs. But at the end of the day, it's still mostly comprised of ham-fisted, juvenile songs about sex and drinking, delivered with a bare minimum of imagination or originality. I'm not sure if Nickelback deserves every bit of the hate directed at them - there are much, much worse artists out there soaking up airwaves and bandwidth - but it's hard to defend them when their track record is this disappointing.
. . . Well, there you have it. Relative Pitch is now officially caught up to the present. That's the long version; stay tuned for a more concise breakdown of my personal Top 10 albums of the year.